• October 31, 2026

Antisemitism in schools and colleges in England: a flawed report that needs critical appraisal and not unconditional endorsement

It seems a reasonable idea to tackle antisemitism, like other forms of prejudice and discrimination in society, by including interventions in schools and colleges in an overall strategy. After all if undesirable attitudes and behaviours can be tackled early in life the chances are greater that they will not so readily be embedded later on. However the government’s recently published report on antisemitism in schools and colleges is flawed in a number of ways which mean that it does not deserve the uncritical endorsement it has received. A blinkered approach to framing of the problem, lack of critical appraisal of the evidence and poorly thought through proposals for action mean that not only may it not be effective, it may prove counter-productive.

First and most obvious is the limited focus of the report, solely on matters directly related to antisemitism – as if it could be possible to explain something with such complicated social and cultural roots without reference to other and possibly overlapping phenomena. The terms of reference offer twelve possible questions the report could consider, ten of which refer only to antisemitism, one of which refers to a need to respect “different faith and ethnic groups including Jewish students and staff” and another refers vaguely to “other discriminatory behaviour”. The report itself embraces this blinkered approach, with at least ten of its recommendations referring only to antisemitism while others when they do mention the need to consider context return repeatedly to a phrase in the terms of reference referring to “other forms of hatred and prejudice” which remain unspecified throughout.

The justification for this approach seems to be that antisemitism is sui generis so that understanding and responding to it can be considered in isolation. At least showing some awareness of a need to defend the claim of antisemitism’s uniqueness, the report provides a list of its features; it is far from convincing as indicating that antisemitism has features that other forms of prejudice and discrimination do not have.

The resulting narrowness of perspective manifests in the sources used in the report. Seventeen of the footnoted references come from surveys undertaken by two organisations (Jewish Policy Research and Community Security Trust) with no wider search for relevant surveys or reports – for example about the well-being of children and young people or about hate crime statistics– that might indicate where concerns about racism in general or antisemitism or islamophobia in particular might fit into their concerns. To give one example: both the terms of reference and the report itself cite an increase in antisemitism after the Hamas attacks in October 2023, but neither mentions that there was a similar increase in reported islamophobic hate crime in England and Wales. In fact islamophobic and antisemitic hate crimes run in parallel apart from a big spike in islamophobic crime coinciding with the Southport murders. The inter-twining of these two forms of anti-religious discrimination is widely discussed in the literature and seen as an indication for tackling the two in an integrated plan – but you wouldn’t know it from the report.

Coupled with the limitations in source material is a striking lack of critical appraisal of the evidence. Survey results are presented with no indication of the response rate or profile of responders so that it is impossible to determine the degree to which response bias or ascertainment bias might influence the results. To give one example, a survey of young people registered with UCAS generated just over 5000 responses which sounds a lot but represents barely more than 1% of the total number of students registered in the year in question. The report’s authors lament the low number of responses coming from students identified as Jewish but even with this small number Jews were overrepresented in the resulting sample. Results in the report are presented almost entirely as percentages with no absolute numbers, a sign that they have not been subject to scrutiny at a level that will enable representativeness or likely accuracy to be assessed.

Much of the document refers to antisemitism as if it is obvious what is being talked about. The IHRA definition is used in the report, including its accompanying examples, but that doesn’t capture the problem.  Antisemitism is a composite term with a wide range of possible inclusions – from occasional insensitive teasing through sustained bullying to life-threatening violence. Without some attention to this problem of specification, questions like how incidence or change are to be measured cannot be answered.

The basis and likely consequences of the report’s recommendations have not been explored in any depth.

For example the need for better Holocaust education (including the centrality of antisemitism) sounds uncontentious and has been widely taken up and supported. However, time spent on education is a zero-sum game and something else must give.  I have been surprised by how few people know about Aktion T4, the Nazi programme of murder of adults and children with special needs who were being housed in the country’s asylums. Or that homosexuality was a reason to be sent to the camps – and the origin of its association with the colour pink. These are not trivial observations in a world in which homophobia and abuse of the disabled between them are several times commoner than all forms of anti-religious hate crime combined.

There is another wider lesson to be learned from study of the rise of Nazism, which did indeed lead to the death of millions of Jews but also to the death of millions of others in a World War the roots of which lay in extreme nationalism and its political enabler fascism. We live in times where the rise of far-right political parties, extreme nationalist views and antipathy towards outsiders (typically from Muslim dominant countries) represents a major threat to the nature of our society. Who would have thought we would see again Blackshirts parading on our streets? Perhaps rather than teaching only that understanding antisemitism is “a central explanatory factor in explaining the Holocaust” we should be teaching also that the key enabling factor was the emergence of a totalitarian racist state?

The report makes sensible and important comments about the value of teaching that emphasises social cohesion and cultural engagement but then the associated recommendations refer only to Judaism and Jewish life. Some attention to the similarities between the Abrahamic religions and the likelihood that much of family life is influenced by social context rather than religious belief thereby gets lost in the preoccupation with tackling antisemitism.

The report cautions against teachers taking political positions, while at the same time they have to confront high levels of societal sexism, sexual harassment and violence against girls and women. None of the three main Abrahamic religions has a great track record when it comes to their approach to the status of women. Can handling any of this in schools be managed without acknowledging and discussing the tension between conservative religious attitudes and western feminist practice?

How will the effect of any of this be measured? Schools are required specifically to record antisemitic incidents but that in itself is not easy when the possibilities range from low level teasing to life threatening violence. Schools and colleges need to balance their response to antisemitism with numerous other demands on their time and capacity to deal with other forms of discrimination: the report offers no guidance other than repeated vague reference to the need to consider other forms of hatred and prejudice.

There is a risk that insensitive preoccupation with tackling antisemitism will not only crowd out the need for similar action in other areas but might even provoke a backlash. There is a huge amount of ill feeling about Israel’s actions in Gaza and the West Bank and the ineffective opposition to it or even support for it coming from the USA and a number of countries in Western Europe. Antisemitism, opposition to the state of Israel in its current form, to Zionism or to this conflict is not conflated only by antisemites but deliberately by elements of the Israeli government and Zionist extremists elsewhere. In this climate we might ask an important question: MP Diane Abbott’s (admittedly clumsy) suggestion that anti-black prejudice was a special case led to an immediate backlash (strapline – there’s no hierarchy of racism). Why would treating antisemitism as a special case not do the same?

Of course antisemitism is awful and the threat of violence against Jews is real, and of course accurate teaching about the Holocaust is an important part of teaching about Nazism and WW2. But if we are to take it seriously we have to do better than the uncritical acclamation offered by education minister Lucy Powell.  The report of the independent review on antisemitism in schools and colleges in England should be taken as a prompt for public debate not as a blueprint for immediate action.

Allan House

E-mail : a.o.house@gmail.com

error

Subscribe to keep updated!